Small Town Mysteries
Small Town Mysteries
Latest Episodes
200th Episode Q&A
In this episode, we talk about it all! What our favorites were, how we research for cases, and what cases we would recommend for those of you who are new to Small Town Mysteries! We close out the episode with a case update.
When DNA Is(n't) Enough
When beloved schoolteacher Genai Coleman was shot while reading her Bible in her car, detectives thought they had an open-and-shut case after finding a cigarette butt in the stolen vehicle that matched suspect Donald Smith’s DNA. However, the i...
The Boy in the Walls: The Gustafson Family Tragedy
What starts as a series of strange, ghost-like pranks against a local family escalates into one of Massachusetts' most shocking crimes. We examine the 1987 murders of Priscilla, Abigail, and William Gustafson, and the terrifying intruder who li...
The Man in the Hat
Kassandra Cantrell was 10 weeks pregnant when she went missing from Tacoma, Washington, in August 2020. Security footage showed a mysterious man in a hat hovering around Kassandra's car, along with other suspicious movements. Who was this man, ...
Coerced: The Gary Gauger Story
In 1993, Gary Gauger woke up to find his parents brutally murdered on their Illinois farm, only to quickly find himself targeted as the prime suspect. After a grueling, 19-hour interrogation filled with psychological pressure and police decepti...
Fan Mail
👋 Hi! I’ve been listening for a long time and tried to send you a pic of my dog on instagram but it wouldn't let me so hopefully this works. Meet Bailey! (It's a boy Bailey) glad to have you guys back! I hope all is well with the little ones!
Elmira, New York
.jpg)
